This page summarizes and comments on a published court decision. It is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts. Unless this page says otherwise, The Eskesen Law Firm did not represent any party in this case.
Bottom line
When an expert’s method is challenged, the party offering the expert must show that the method is generally accepted in the field and was properly applied to the facts of the case. Here, the First Department upheld the exclusion of the defense’s biomechanical engineer at the trial of a woman injured in a crash involving a truck, but it found the jury’s $2,000,000 award for her past pain and suffering too high and ordered a new trial on that item unless she agrees to $1,350,000.
The case
- Court
- Appellate Division, First Department
- Decided
- November 12, 2026
- Case
- Larrea v Sanitation Salvage Corp.
- Citation
- 2026 NY Slip Op 06575
- Official text
- Read the decision on the New York courts’ official reporter site
The facts
The plaintiff was injured in a crash between her vehicle and a truck with a large metal construction container attached. She sued Sanitation Salvage Corp. and others in the Supreme Court, Bronx County. The trial court directed the defense’s proposed biomechanical expert to testify at a Frye hearing, a hearing on whether an expert’s method is generally accepted in the field, and then barred him from testifying at trial. She had undergone C5-C6 anterior cervical discectomy and interbody fusion surgery (a neck fusion), with a titanium plate and a plastic cage incorporated with cadaver bone, affixed with screws. The jury awarded her $2,000,000 for past pain and suffering. The defendants moved for a new trial on damages, arguing that the expert should not have been excluded, or in the alternative to set aside that award. The court denied the motion, and they appealed.
The holding
The First Department unanimously modified. The record was “insufficient to review” the defendants’ claim that the court should not have ordered a Frye hearing, because “[t]here is no transcript memorializing plaintiff’s oral application or defendants’ opposition, if any, before the parties proceeded with that hearing” (2026 NY Slip Op 06575, *1). The trial court “providently exercised its discretion” in excluding the expert, “as defendants failed to sustain their burden of demonstrating that the expert’s methodology—his own injury causation analysis—was generally accepted in the field of biomechanics” (id.). Nor did they show that his opinions “related to existing data and were the result of a proper application of accepted methodology in this particular case” (id. at *2). He “relied on assumptions about the accident that were not supported by evidence in the record, such as the weight of the two vehicles,” and did not know about, among other things, the truck’s attached container, its weight, the position of her body, the type of seatbelt and headrest in her vehicle, or her testimony “that her vehicle moved about nine feet forward despite having her foot on the brake” (id.). His opinion “lacked probative value” (id.). On damages, the $2,000,000 award “deviated materially from what would be reasonable compensation and should be reduced to $1,350,000” (id., citing CPLR 5501[c]).
What changed
Nothing new: this applies settled law, including the court’s earlier decisions in De La Rosa v Nelson Ave. Holdings (199 AD3d 513 [1st Dept 2021]) and Ruiz v Losito (226 AD3d 627 [1st Dept 2024]).
What it means
- When the method is challenged, the side offering the expert must show that it is generally accepted. Here, the defense did not show that the engineer’s “own injury causation analysis” was.
- Even an accepted method must be applied to the real facts. An opinion built on assumptions the record does not support may be kept from the jury.
- Objections belong on the record. The challenge to holding the Frye hearing could not be reviewed, because there was no transcript of the request for the hearing or of any opposition to it.
- An appellate court may reduce an award it finds “deviated materially” from reasonable compensation. Here, she must accept $1,350,000 for past pain and suffering or face a new trial on that item.
Our view
Commentary by Frank N. Eskesen. This section is opinion.
This is our fourth entry on a defense biomechanical opinion, after Bonilla-Acosta v Max Servs. Corp. (Second Department, October 14, 2026), Latazela v Compass Six Owner LLC (First Department, October 15, 2026), and Gonzalez v Chatsworth Bldrs. LLC (First Department, October 20, 2026), and the first in which a court barred the expert from testifying at trial. In our view, the court’s reasoning is sound. An analysis of how a crash injured someone is only as good as the facts that support it. Here, the engineer did not know about the container on the truck or her testimony that her vehicle moved about nine feet with her foot on the brake. He also “did not know that the tape on plaintiff’s vehicle, as shown in the photographs he used for his report, was not there before the accident,” and he agreed that it hid some of the damage (2026 NY Slip Op 06575, *2). Two lessons: 1. After a crash, if you are able, photograph both vehicles before anything is repaired or covered, and follow your doctor’s advice. 2. For lawyers, test a defense biomechanical opinion against the record (the vehicles, the load, the seating position, and the safety equipment), and put every request and objection about a Frye hearing on the record.
Topics
Court: First Department. Year: 2026. Statutes: CPLR 5501(c). Result: modified.
Reviewed by Frank N. Eskesen, admitted in New York since 2000. Decided November 12, 2026. Posted November 16, 2026.
Questions about your own accident?
Call us for a free consultation. Calls answered live 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.