This page summarizes and comments on a published court decision. It is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts. Unless this page says otherwise, The Eskesen Law Firm did not represent any party in this case.
Bottom line
A defendant’s motion to dismiss, made at the very start of a case before answering the complaint, can succeed if documentary evidence utterly refutes the plaintiff’s factual allegations, and a videotape can count as documentary evidence if it is sufficiently authenticated. Here, the Second Department dismissed claims by the occupants of a car against UPS because a dashboard-camera video, authenticated by the UPS driver, showed that the UPS truck was stopped at the time of impact and did not strike their car.
The case
- Court
- Appellate Division, Second Department
- Decided
- November 18, 2026
- Case
- Callender v United Parcel Service, Inc.
- Citation
- Second Department decision D82264 (slip opinion number not yet assigned)
- Official text
- Read the court’s own decision file
The facts
On November 28, 2023, at about 7:00 p.m., a UPS package delivery driver was driving a truck owned by United Parcel Service, Inc. northbound on Gates Avenue when he was involved in an accident with a southbound white Toyota Camry occupied by the plaintiffs. They sued in June 2024, alleging that the UPS vehicle “came into contact” with their car. Before answering, UPS moved to dismiss the first and second causes of action against it under CPLR 3211(a)(1), based on a dashboard-camera video that, it said, showed its truck stopped in bumper-to-bumper traffic when the accident occurred. The plaintiffs pointed out that the video did not show the impact. The Supreme Court, Kings County, denied that part of UPS’s motion for that reason, and UPS appealed. The complaint also named another defendant, which was not part of the appeal.
The holding
The Second Department, which calls UPS “United,” reversed and granted that part of UPS’s motion. “A videotape may be considered documentary evidence if sufficiently authenticated” (decision p 2). “Here, the videotape was authenticated by the driver of the United vehicle, who stated that the videotape was a true and accurate depiction of events” (id.). “The videotape established that the United vehicle was stopped at the time of impact and did not strike the vehicle occupied by the plaintiffs” (id.). Other southbound vehicles, “including a city bus, successfully passed the United vehicle without incident” (id.). The court rejected, as speculation, a suggestion raised at oral argument in the Supreme Court that a parcel or a bumper sticking out of the back of the truck could have caused the accident (id.). “Under these facts, the videotape constituted documentary evidence which conclusively established that the plaintiffs have no cause of action” (id.).
What changed
Nothing new: this applies settled law, including the court’s earlier decision in Fontanetta v John Doe 1 (73 AD3d 78 [2d Dept 2010]), which explains what counts as documentary evidence.
What it means
- A motion under CPLR 3211(a)(1), which can be made at the start of a case, can end a claim, but only if the documentary evidence “utterly refutes” the injured person’s factual allegations (decision p 2, quoting the Court of Appeals). Here, the court treated an authenticated dashcam video as documentary evidence.
- Authentication matters. Here, the UPS driver stated that the video was a true and accurate depiction of events.
Our view
Commentary by Frank N. Eskesen. This section is opinion.
This decision and Rafailova v Vucciria Food Gourmet (Second Department, November 18, 2026), decided the same day, show two sides of video evidence. In Rafailova, store video helped win an injured shopper summary judgment on liability. Here, a truck’s dashcam video led to dismissal of the claims against UPS on a motion UPS made before answering the complaint. Compare our entries on Walsh v Singho (First Department, November 10, 2026), where a dashcam video helped an injured passenger’s claim go forward, and Pemberton v Liberty Ashes Inc. (First Department, October 27, 2026), where a truck’s dashcam showed that the bicyclist rode through a red light. As we said in Walsh, a dashcam does not take sides. Two lessons: 1. If you are hurt in a crash with a delivery truck or other commercial vehicle, get legal advice promptly and ask early whether the vehicle had a camera. The video may help your claim or hurt it, and it is better to know which before a lawsuit is filed (see our post on why early evidence matters). 2. For lawyers, when a defendant moves to dismiss on a video at the start of a case, look closely at what the video does and does not show, and at who authenticated it and how.
Topics
Court: Second Department. Year: 2026. Statutes: CPLR 3211(a)(1). Result: reversed.
Reviewed by Frank N. Eskesen, admitted in New York since 2000. Decided November 18, 2026. Posted November 18, 2026.
Questions about your own accident?
Call us for a free consultation. Calls answered live 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.