This page summarizes and comments on a published court decision. It is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts. Unless this page says otherwise, The Eskesen Law Firm did not represent any party in this case.
Bottom line
An injured person can win on liability before trial when the evidence leaves no real question that the defendant’s negligence caused the accident, and an argument that the hazard was open and obvious bears on the injured person’s own share of fault but does not defeat liability. Here, the Second Department affirmed summary judgment on liability for a shopper because the evidence, including surveillance video, showed a store employee create a bump in a rubber mat and try, without success, to smooth it down with his foot, and about 10 minutes later she caught her foot on it and fell.
The case
- Court
- Appellate Division, Second Department
- Decided
- November 18, 2026
- Case
- Rafailova v Vucciria Food Gourmet
- Citation
- Second Department decision D82366 (slip opinion number not yet assigned)
- Official text
- Read the court’s own decision file
The facts
The plaintiff alleges that she tripped and fell on a rubber mat while shopping in a supermarket owned by Vucciria Food Gourmet and Orchard King Corp. After discovery, she moved for summary judgment on liability against those two defendants, and they moved for summary judgment dismissing her complaint against them. The Supreme Court, Kings County, granted her motion and denied theirs, and on reargument it adhered to that ruling. The two defendants appealed. The complaint also named another defendant, which was not part of the appeal.
The holding
The Second Department affirmed the ruling made on reargument. The plaintiff “satisfied her prima facie burden by submitting, among other things, a surveillance video of the accident which showed that the defendants’ employee created a bump in the rubber mat, which the employee unsuccessfully attempted to smooth down with his foot, and, approximately 10 minutes later, the plaintiff caught her left foot on the raised portion of the rubber mat, causing her to trip and fall” (decision p 2). “In opposition, the defendants failed to raise a triable issue of fact” (id.). Their argument that the mat was open and obvious did not help them, because “[w]hether a condition is open and obvious is relevant to a plaintiff’s comparative fault, but does not negate liability” (id., quoting Naftaliyeva v Shoprite of Ave. I, 233 AD3d 793, 795).
What changed
Nothing new: this applies settled law, including the court’s earlier decision in Naftaliyeva v Shoprite of Ave. I (233 AD3d 793 [2d Dept 2024]).
What it means
- Video can show not only how someone fell but how the hazard got there. Here, surveillance video showed the defendants’ own employee create the bump in the mat about 10 minutes before the fall.
- An argument that a hazard was “open and obvious” did not defeat liability here. In the court’s words, quoting its earlier decision, “[w]hether a condition is open and obvious is relevant to a plaintiff’s comparative fault, but does not negate liability” (decision p 2).
Our view
Commentary by Frank N. Eskesen. This section is opinion.
Many store cases turn on one question. Did the store create the hazard that caused the injury, or did the store know, or should it have known, about the hazard? Without proof on that point, a case against a store can fail. Here, the video answered the question without depending on anyone’s memory. It objectively showed the defendants’ employee create the bump and try without success to smooth it down, and then showed the fall about 10 minutes later. Compare this positive outcome for a plaintiff with our entry on Callender v United Parcel Service, Inc. (Second Department, November 18, 2026), decided the same day as this case, where a dashcam video ended the car occupants’ claims against UPS. Two lessons: 1. If you fall in a store, tell the store that you want its video kept, note where the cameras are, and get legal advice promptly, so that a preservation letter can go out before the video is recorded over (see our post on preservation letters). With cameras in more and more places, video may be the best evidence of what happened. 2. For lawyers, when the evidence shows the defendant created the hazard, consider moving for summary judgment on liability. Here, the court held that the open and obvious argument went to comparative fault, not to liability.
Topics
Court: Second Department. Year: 2026. Result: affirmed.
Reviewed by Frank N. Eskesen, admitted in New York since 2000. Decided November 18, 2026. Posted November 18, 2026.
Questions about your own accident?
Call us for a free consultation. Calls answered live 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.