Decision Day

“Clearly Inadequate” Search Affidavits in a Fall Case, and Surveillance Video That Was Ultimately Produced: Money Sanctions, but the Defendants’ Answers Stand (Kolenovic v JPMorgan Chase Bank, 1st Dept 2026)

This page summarizes and comments on a published court decision. It is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts. Unless this page says otherwise, The Eskesen Law Firm did not represent any party in this case.

Bottom line

When a defendant mishandles discovery, the trial court has discretion to choose the sanction, and striking the defendant’s answer is a drastic step. Here, the First Department held that the trial court acted within its discretion when it ordered monetary sanctions against two Chase entities and Jones Lang LaSalle for improper conduct during discovery, including “clearly inadequate search affidavits,” but did not strike their answers, especially given that the surveillance video the plaintiff demanded was ultimately produced.

The case

Court
Appellate Division, First Department
Decided
November 17, 2026
Case
Kolenovic v JPMorgan Chase Bank
Citation
2026 NY Slip Op 06773
Official text
Read the decision on the New York courts’ official reporter site

The facts

The plaintiff sued JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. and Chase Bank, also known as JPMorgan Chase & Co. (the Chase defendants), Jones Lang LaSalle Americas, Inc. (JLL), and others over an accident in which the plaintiff fell. The decision does not say where or how. JLL’s project manager was on an email chain with the Chase defendants’ head of global security, who stated that there was surveillance video from the time period of the accident. Those emails also indicated that the fall itself was not visible on the video, and nothing showed that JLL ever had the footage or that any JLL employee reviewed it. According to the evidence, at Chase the litigation was handled by its insurance claims department, while the video was preserved within its global security department. The plaintiff moved to strike the answers of the Chase defendants and JLL. The Supreme Court, New York County, awarded monetary discovery sanctions against them but declined to strike their answers, and the plaintiff appealed.

The holding

The First Department unanimously affirmed. As to Chase, “[t]here was no communication between these departments regarding the matter” (2026 NY Slip Op 06773, *1). The court held that “[t]he apparent lack of communication within and among defendants and the production of clearly inadequate search affidavits constituted improper conduct during discovery” (id.). “However, it was not an abuse of discretion for the court to conclude that these factors did not necessarily rise to the level of willful, contumacious, or bad faith misconduct” (id.). So “the court did not abuse its discretion by awarding monetary sanctions rather than striking defendants’ pleadings, especially given that the demanded video was ultimately produced” (id.).

What changed

Nothing new: this applies settled law, including the Court of Appeals’ decision in Kihl v Pfeffer (94 NY2d 118 [1999]) and the court’s earlier decision in De Socio v 136 E. 56th St. Owners, Inc. (74 AD3d 606 [1st Dept 2010]).

What it means

  1. Surveillance video can sit in one part of a company while another part handles the claim. Here, the video was kept by the Chase defendants’ global security department, while their insurance claims department handled the litigation.
  2. A sworn statement that a defendant searched for evidence can be challenged. The court called the search affidavits here “clearly inadequate.”
  3. Striking a defendant’s answer is a drastic step. Here, the trial court could conclude that the conduct did not necessarily rise to the level of “willful, contumacious, or bad faith misconduct” (in plain terms, deliberate or defiant conduct, or bad faith), and with the video ultimately produced, it could choose money sanctions instead.

Our view

Commentary by Frank N. Eskesen. This section is opinion.

This case shows how evidence can be hard to find inside a large company, even when nobody destroys it. According to the decision, the Chase defendants’ global security department preserved the video, their insurance claims department handled the litigation, and there was no communication between the two departments about the matter. The defendants’ search affidavits were, in the court’s words, “clearly inadequate.” The consequence was money sanctions. The video was ultimately produced, and the court did not take the harsher step the plaintiff asked for, striking the defendants’ answers, which can leave a defendant unable to contest liability. Compare our entry on Fernandez v Port Auth. of N.Y. & N.J. (Second Department, September 30, 2026), where video was overwritten and the court held that a jury should decide whether spoliation occurred. Here, the video survived. In our view, choosing money sanctions over striking the answers was within the trial court’s discretion on this record. Two lessons: 1. If you are hurt in a bank, store, office building, or other place of business, get legal advice promptly so that a preservation letter can go out to everyone who may hold video, including the business, the building’s owner, and any company managing it (see our post on preservation letters). 2. For lawyers, when a defendant submits a search affidavit, test it with questions such as who searched, which departments, and which systems. The answer may be in a department the claim handlers never called.

Topics

Spoliation and EvidenceProcedure and Affirmations

Court: First Department. Year: 2026. Statutes: CPLR 3126. Result: affirmed.

Reviewed by Frank N. Eskesen, admitted in New York since 2000. Decided November 17, 2026. Posted November 18, 2026.

Questions about your own accident?

Call us for a free consultation. Calls answered live 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.

(212) 433-4500

All Decision Day entries

Free consultation

Legal Help When You Need It

Fill out the form to request a consultation and we will be in touch as soon as possible.

(212) 433-4500

Toll-free 1-800-321-NYLAW (1-800-321-6952)

  • Calls answered live 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
  • We speak English, Spanish and Portuguese.
  • Main office
    450 Seventh Avenue, Suite 1808
    New York, NY 10123
  • Downtown office
    30 Wall Street, Suite 804
    New York, NY 10005
    By appointment only

Send us a message

There is no charge to ask. We will get back to you as soon as possible. For anything urgent, call (212) 433-4500.

The date, the place and the type of accident are enough; we will get the details when we speak with you.