Spoliation and Evidence
Decisions on lost or destroyed evidence, such as overwritten surveillance video, and the sanctions courts can impose.
-
Sidewalk Fall: Google Maps Images Did Not Win Dismissal When Testimony the Defendants Submitted Backed the Injured Woman’s Photo (Then v Meridian Realty Inc., 1st Dept 2026)
A defendant that asks to dismiss a fall case because the injured person cannot say what made her fall still must prove that point, and the testimony it submits counts against it too. Here, the First Department reinstated a woman’s sidewalk fall claim against two defendants, because testimony they themselves submitted agreed that her photo of the defect fairly and accurately showed the area at the time, even though Google Maps images from before and after her fall did not show it.
-
Pedestrian Struck in a Brooklyn Crosswalk: Comparative Negligence Defense Dismissed Because the Defense Conceded Full Liability (Cuautle-Rosas v Caprio, 2d Dept 2026)
When the defense in a crash case concedes full liability, its claim that the injured person was partly at fault should be dismissed. Here, the Second Department held that the comparative negligence defense should have been dismissed in the case of a woman struck by a car while walking in a Brooklyn crosswalk, and required the driver’s wife and son to give depositions, but it did not strike the defendant’s answer over video disclosed late, and it did not allow a demand for punitive damages.
-
Intersection Crash Gets a New Trial: A Driver With the Right of Way Must Still Use Reasonable Care, and Photos of the Vehicle Damage Should Have Been Admitted (Pruessen v Richard Capobianco, Inc., 2d Dept 2026)
A driver with the right of way may assume that others will yield, but still must use reasonable care to avoid hitting a vehicle that is already in the intersection. Here, the Second Department reinstated a driver’s case that had been dismissed at the close of her evidence at trial, and held that photographs of the damage to both vehicles should have been admitted at the trial on fault.
-
Bus Video Defeats a Passenger’s Claim Against NYC Transit Despite the Other Driver’s Sworn Account (Hyejun Cho v NYCTA, 2d Dept 2026)
When clear video shows how a crash happened, a court may decide fault without a trial, even if a driver swears to a different version. Here, the Second Department affirmed the dismissal of a car passenger’s claims against the New York City Transit Authority and its bus driver, because the bus video conclusively established that the driver of the car she was riding in was the sole proximate cause of the crash.
-
E-Bike Rider’s Claim Against NYC Transit: An Early Summary Judgment Motion Was Not Premature, but Unclear Video Was Not Enough (Komlan v Belisle, 1st Dept 2026)
The fact that depositions have not occurred in a motor vehicle accident case does not necessarily preclude the court from granting summary judgment, but the proof must still show the defendants’ negligence clearly. Here, the First Department held that an e-bike rider’s motion against the New York City Transit Authority was not premature, but because the surveillance video did not clearly depict the accident, it affirmed the trial court’s denial of the motion.
-
Slip-and-Fall Video Overwritten After a Preservation Letter: Adverse Inference Charge Ordered (Fernandez v Port Auth. of N.Y. & N.J., 2d Dept 2026)
Where there is a question of fact as to the time a preservation letter is received and the time when the video is destroyed, the jury is to determine whether “spoliation of evidence” occurred. Here, in a slip-and-fall case against an airline, the Second Department held that “[t]he appropriate sanction” for any spoliation “would be an adverse inference charge” against the airline.
Decision Day summarizes and comments on published court decisions. It is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts. Unless an entry says otherwise, The Eskesen Law Firm did not represent any party in these cases.
Legal Help When You Need It
Fill out the form to request a consultation and we will be in touch as soon as possible.
(212) 433-4500Toll-free 1-800-321-NYLAW (1-800-321-6952)
- Calls answered live 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
- We speak English, Spanish and Portuguese.
- Main office
450 Seventh Avenue, Suite 1808
New York, NY 10123 - Downtown office
30 Wall Street, Suite 804
New York, NY 10005
By appointment only