Decision Day

Principal Allegedly Hurt Trying to Stop a Student Fight: Federal Student Privacy Law Does Not Block Court-Ordered Discovery of School Records (Mule v City of New York, 2d Dept 2026)

This page summarizes and comments on a published court decision. It is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts. Unless this page says otherwise, The Eskesen Law Firm did not represent any party in this case.

Bottom line

A federal law, the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA), protects student education records, but it is not violated when records are disclosed under a court order, and a person suing does not have to make a heightened showing to get them. Here, the Second Department reversed an order that had refused, because of FERPA, to require the City of New York and the New York City Board of Education to produce discipline and complaint records about students involved in a fight, and it sent the case back to decide which records, if any, are material and necessary.

The case

Court
Appellate Division, Second Department
Decided
November 18, 2026
Case
Mule v City of New York
Citation
Second Department decision D82357 (slip opinion number not yet assigned)
Official text
Read the court’s own decision file

The facts

The plaintiff, an elementary school principal, alleges that she was injured when she attempted to stop a fight among several students. In March 2022, she sued the City of New York and the New York City Board of Education, alleging, among other things, negligent supervision. In July 2024, she served a notice of discovery and inspection requesting, among other things, school records and “OCR” reports regarding discipline and complaints for the students involved in the fight. In November 2024, she moved to compel the defendants to comply. The defendants opposed. The Supreme Court, Kings County, denied that part of her motion on the ground that FERPA (20 USC § 1232g) precluded disclosure, and she appealed.

The holding

The Second Department reversed that part of the order. The records are subject to FERPA, but the statute “is not violated when disclosure is furnished via a judicial order” (decision p 2). And “[c]ontrary to the defendants’ contention, FERPA does not require a state civil litigant to make a heightened showing when seeking disclosure of education records protected by the statute” (id.). The court sent the matter back to the Supreme Court for a new decision on her motion to compel, “including a determination of which of the subject records, if any, are material and necessary to the plaintiff’s prosecution of this action” (id.).

What changed

Nothing new: this applies settled law, including the court’s earlier decision in Staten v City of New York (90 AD3d 893 [2d Dept 2011]).

What it means

  1. Student records are not off-limits in an injury case. FERPA protects them, but a court can order them produced.
  2. The person asking for them does not have to meet a special, higher standard because FERPA applies.
  3. The court can limit what is produced. Here, the trial court will decide which records, if any, are material and necessary to the case.

Our view

Commentary by Frank N. Eskesen. This section is opinion.

This was the right result. The principal alleged negligent supervision, and she asked for records of discipline and complaints about the students in the fight. Records like these may help show what the school knew about those students before the fight. In our view, a privacy law that is not violated by a court-ordered disclosure should not become a wall around records that may matter to the case. The principal may know some of this firsthand, but a lawsuit runs on proof, and the school’s own records can show what the school knew and when. At the same time, the decision does not open every record. The trial court must still decide which records, if any, are material and necessary to her case. Two lessons: 1. If you or your child is hurt in a fight or other incident at school, write down who was involved and any earlier problems you know about, and get legal advice promptly. A claim against the City or the New York City Board of Education generally requires a Notice of Claim served within 90 days. 2. For lawyers, a FERPA objection is not the end of the discussion. Ask for a court order, and be ready to show which records are material and necessary.

Topics

Notice of Claim and Municipal LiabilityProcedure and Affirmations

Court: Second Department. Year: 2026. Statutes: 20 USC § 1232g; CPLR 3124. Result: reversed.

Reviewed by Frank N. Eskesen, admitted in New York since 2000. Decided November 18, 2026. Posted November 18, 2026.

Questions about your own accident?

Call us for a free consultation. Calls answered live 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.

(212) 433-4500

All Decision Day entries

Free consultation

Legal Help When You Need It

Fill out the form to request a consultation and we will be in touch as soon as possible.

(212) 433-4500

Toll-free 1-800-321-NYLAW (1-800-321-6952)

  • Calls answered live 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
  • We speak English, Spanish and Portuguese.
  • Main office
    450 Seventh Avenue, Suite 1808
    New York, NY 10123
  • Downtown office
    30 Wall Street, Suite 804
    New York, NY 10005
    By appointment only

Send us a message

There is no charge to ask. We will get back to you as soon as possible. For anything urgent, call (212) 433-4500.

The date, the place and the type of accident are enough; we will get the details when we speak with you.