Notice of Claim and Municipal Liability
Decisions on injury claims against New York cities, counties, and public authorities, including the Notice of Claim that generally must be served within 90 days (General Municipal Law § 50-e).
-
Trip Over a Fence Around a Sidewalk Tree Well: The City Is Out for Lack of Prior Written Notice, but the Private Defendants Stay In (Rahman v B & K Realty Assoc., LLC, 2d Dept 2026)
In New York City, an abutting property owner generally is not responsible under the sidewalk law for injuries in a City-owned tree well, but it may be if it created the dangerous condition there. Here, the Second Department reinstated a pedestrian’s claim against four private defendants over a wooden fence around a tree well, because they did not affirmatively show that they had not created the condition, while it affirmed dismissal against the City, which showed it had no prior written notice.
-
Late Notice of Claim Denied: Police Records of a Motorcycle Crash Did Not Give the City Actual Knowledge of a Claim Against Its Officers (Matter of Connolly v City of New York, 1st Dept 2026)
When the 90-day deadline to serve a Notice of Claim on the City is missed, a court deciding whether to allow a late one weighs whether the City learned the essential facts of the claim in time, and a record showing only that an accident happened may not be enough. Here, the First Department affirmed the denial of a motorcyclist’s request to serve a late Notice of Claim, because the police records he relied on did not mention any wrongful acts by officers, and he offered no medical records to support his claim that his injuries kept him from serving on time.
-
Collision With a Fire Truck Going Through a Red Light on an Emergency Call: Claim Dismissed Under the Reckless Disregard Standard (Blackshear v City of Yonkers, 2d Dept 2026)
The driver of an emergency vehicle on an emergency call, using its lights and siren, may go through a red light after slowing down as necessary for safety, and for doing so can be held liable only if the driver acted in reckless disregard for the safety of others. Here, the Second Department affirmed the dismissal of a claim by a driver who had a green light when his vehicle collided with a City of Yonkers fire truck, because the fire truck was responding to an emergency call with its lights and siren on, and its driver slowed sufficiently before entering the intersection.
-
Crosswalk Fall in Queens: A “Dotted Line” on a Big Apple Map Was Not Prior Written Notice to the City (Melendez v City of New York, 2d Dept 2026)
New York City generally cannot be held liable for a defect in a street or crosswalk unless it had prior written notice of that specific defect, and a Big Apple map can serve as that notice only if it marks the defect that caused the fall. Here, the Second Department affirmed the dismissal of a man’s claim for a fall in a Queens crosswalk, because the City’s records search showed no prior written notice, and a “dotted line” on a Big Apple map did not match any defect symbol in the map’s key.
-
Student Hurt Amid a Crowd at School: Late Notice of Claim Denied Because the School’s Reports Showed an Accident, Not a Claim (Matter of T. C. v New York City Department of Education, 2d Dept 2026)
A claim against a public school generally must start with a Notice of Claim served within 90 days, and when a court decides whether to allow a late one, it gives great importance to whether the school knew the essential facts of the claim in time, not just that an accident happened. Here, the Second Department affirmed the denial of a request to serve a late Notice of Claim for a student’s broken ankle, because no reasonable excuse was offered and the reports submitted with the petition did not show a potentially actionable failure to supervise.
-
Trip on a Bump in a City Park Path: Claim Dismissed Because the City Showed It Had No Prior Written Notice (Maldonado v City of New York, 1st Dept 2026)
New York City generally cannot be held liable for a defect covered by its prior written notice law unless it had written notice beforehand, but to win dismissal before trial the City must first show that it had none. Here, the First Department affirmed the dismissal of a claim by a man who alleged he tripped on a two- or three-inch bump in an asphalt path in Van Cortlandt Park, because the City’s records search showed no written complaints and his evidence did not raise a question of fact.
-
Fall on the Riegelmann Boardwalk: City’s “No Prior Written Notice” Defense Fails Because Its Records Search Was Not Shown to Be Complete (Young v City of New York, 2d Dept 2026)
A New York City law generally makes the City liable for a defect in its streets and sidewalks only if it had prior written notice of it, but to have a claim dismissed on that ground before trial, the City must first show that it had none. Here, the Second Department reversed the dismissal of a man’s claim for a fall on the Riegelmann Boardwalk in Brooklyn, because the City’s affidavit did not say unequivocally that its records search found no prior written notice, and did not show that all the relevant records were searched.
-
Trip on a Fire Hydrant Base: Claim Against the Building Owner Dismissed Because the City Was Responsible for the Hydrant (Fung v Exxon Mobil Oil Corp., 2d Dept 2026)
In New York City, the owner of the building or lot that a sidewalk runs in front of (the “abutting” owner) must keep that sidewalk reasonably safe, but it may not be responsible for a fire hydrant on the sidewalk that it does not own, control, or maintain. Here, the Second Department affirmed the dismissal of a pedestrian’s claim against the abutting owner after his foot caught on a fire hydrant base, because the owner showed that the City was responsible for maintaining the hydrant.
-
Ambulance Allegedly Sent Without Oxygen: Wrongful Death Claim Against NYC Fails for Lack of a Special Duty (Davis v City of New York, 2d Dept 2026)
When a city sends an ambulance in response to a 911 call, it is performing a governmental function, and it can be held liable only if it owed the injured person a “special duty.” Here, the Second Department held that the City’s motion to dismiss a wrongful death complaint should have been granted because no such duty was alleged, even though a discovery sanction barred the City from offering evidence on liability.
-
Late Notice of Claim Denied: Another Police Department’s Accident Report Did Not Give the Village Notice (Matter of Defonce v Village of Port Chester, 2d Dept 2026)
When a Notice of Claim deadline is missed, a court considers whether the public body learned the essential facts in time, whether there is a reasonable excuse, and whether the delay hurt its defense. Here, the Second Department affirmed the denial of an injured police officer’s request to serve a late Notice of Claim, holding that an accident report prepared by a different police department did not give the Village of Port Chester actual knowledge of his claim.
-
Emailing a Notice of Claim to NYC Transit Is Not Valid Service (Kopitova v NYCTA, 2d Dept 2026)
Unless email is an authorized method of service for a Notice of Claim, claimants must ensure that papers are served in a manner that the law allows. Here, the Second Department upheld the dismissal of an injured woman’s case, ruling that even though an NYCTA lawyer received the emailed Claim, NYCTA’s prompt rejection required the Claimant to serve by authorized means.
-
Late Notice of Claim Allowed Against NYC Transit Because a Passenger’s Timely Notice Covered the Same Crash (Matter of Tkebuchava v NYCTA, 2d Dept 2026)
A missed 90-day deadline does not always end a case. Here, the driver of a car hit by a New York City Transit Authority bus missed the deadline, but a passenger on the bus had served her own timely Notice of Claim, which gave the authority actual knowledge of the essential facts, and the authority made no showing that the delay hurt its defense.
Decision Day summarizes and comments on published court decisions. It is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts. Unless an entry says otherwise, The Eskesen Law Firm did not represent any party in these cases.
Legal Help When You Need It
Fill out the form to request a consultation and we will be in touch as soon as possible.
(212) 433-4500Toll-free 1-800-321-NYLAW (1-800-321-6952)
- Calls answered live 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
- We speak English, Spanish and Portuguese.
- Main office
450 Seventh Avenue, Suite 1808
New York, NY 10123 - Downtown office
30 Wall Street, Suite 804
New York, NY 10005
By appointment only