This page summarizes and comments on a published court decision. It is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts. Unless this page says otherwise, The Eskesen Law Firm did not represent any party in this case.
Bottom line
When asking a court to dismiss a fire case before trial, a building owner must leave no real question about its own safety failures, and testimony from the people who lived there can create that question. Here, the First Department kept alive a negligence claim against the owner of a Manhattan apartment building where a woman died in a fire, because there were questions of fact about the smoke alarms, a self-closing door, and the superintendent’s fire-safety training, but it dismissed a separate claim for negligent infliction of emotional distress.
The case
- Court
- Appellate Division, First Department
- Decided
- November 12, 2026
- Case
- De Los Santos v 512-514 Realty LLC
- Citation
- 2026 NY Slip Op 06570
- Official text
- Read the decision on the New York courts’ official reporter site
The facts
A woman died in a fire in an apartment building at 512 West 136th Street in Manhattan. The plaintiffs, who lived on the building’s sixth floor, sued the building’s owner, 512-514 Realty LLC. They alleged that it negligently caused her death by failing to maintain the building’s smoke alarms, by failing to maintain the self-closing hinges on the door to apartment 4, where the fire apparently started, and by failing to train its superintendent in fire safety. They also claimed negligent infliction of emotional distress. The owner moved for summary judgment dismissing the complaint. The Supreme Court, New York County, denied the motion, and the owner appealed.
The holding
The First Department unanimously modified the order to dismiss the emotional distress claim, and otherwise affirmed. On the smoke alarms, the owner’s superintendent and vice president testified that the building had working smoke alarms “that were ringing during and after the fire” (2026 NY Slip Op 06570, *1). But the plaintiffs testified “that the smoke alarm in their apartment never worked and that there were no smoke alarms or other audible devices ringing during the fire” (id.). On the door, the owner’s fire investigation expert concluded that it failed to close “because it was impeded by an object, not because the hinges failed” (id.). The plaintiffs answered with “evidence from before the fire showing that the door did not close automatically when tenants used it, as well as photos from after the fire showing that the door remained open without any debris in its path” (id.). Regarding the claim of improper training, the owner did not eliminate questions of fact whether its failure to train the superintendent in fire safety helped cause her death (id. at *2). After the fire started, the superintendent “tied open the front door and opened all the basement doors, and he testified that tying the front door open caused the smoke to go up into the stairwell, where the decedent was later found” (id.). The emotional distress claim failed because one plaintiff told FDNY investigators that he last saw her in their sixth-floor apartment, and testified that “he did not see the decedent sustain any injuries” (id.).
What changed
Nothing new: this applies settled law, including the court’s earlier decision in Mirdita v Musovic Realty Corp. (171 AD3d 662 [1st Dept 2019]).
What it means
- In New York City, the owner of an apartment building must install working smoke alarms in each apartment and keep self-closing doors to hallways and stairs in good repair (see our post on fires in New York City homes and apartments).
- An owner’s own witnesses are not the last word. Tenants’ testimony that their alarm never worked and that no alarm sounded, and photos of the open door with nothing in its way, created questions of fact.
- What building staff do during a fire can matter too.
- The separate emotional distress claim failed on this record, because one plaintiff testified that he did not see the decedent sustain any injuries, and the plaintiffs raised no question of fact in response.
Our view
Commentary by Frank N. Eskesen. This section is opinion.
A fire case can turn on questions about ordinary things: an alarm that may never have worked, a door hinge that may not have operated properly, a front door that the superintendent said he tied open. We believe the court was right to leave these questions to a jury. It also rejected the owner’s point that other residents got out in time, because, even if they did, that did not show “that the fire alarms alerted decedent to the fire and allowed her to safely leave the building” (2026 NY Slip Op 06570, *1). The decision comes days before the City Council’s November 20, 2026, hearing on residential fires, and it shows the duties in our post on fires in New York City homes and apartments (November 11, 2026) at work in court. Two lessons: 1. Never disable your smoke alarm or remove its batteries, and test it regularly. If an alarm or a self-closing door in your building does not work, tell your landlord in writing, keep a copy, and call 311. If you or someone close to you is hurt in a fire, write down what you remember, such as whether alarms sounded and doors were closed, and get legal advice promptly. 2. For lawyers, tenants’ own accounts and evidence from before the fire can raise questions of fact even when an owner offers an expert. A door that does not close can let one apartment’s fire reach the whole building.
Topics
Court: First Department. Year: 2026. Result: modified.
Reviewed by Frank N. Eskesen, admitted in New York since 2000. Decided November 12, 2026. Posted November 16, 2026.
Questions about your own accident?
Call us for a free consultation. Calls answered live 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.