Summary Judgment
Decisions on when a court can decide a case, or part of one, without a trial.
-
Left Turn, Dashcam Video, and a Police Report: Passenger’s Claim Against the Turning Driver Is Reinstated (Walsh v Singho, 1st Dept 2026)
A driver who asks to be let out of a case before trial must eliminate every real question about whether his own fault helped cause the crash, and a police report from an officer who did not see the crash may not do that. Here, the First Department reinstated an injured passenger’s claim against a left-turning driver and the vehicle’s owner, because the dashcam video from the car she was riding in showed the turning vehicle encroaching into the oncoming lane, and the evidence left open whether he should have yielded to a hazard he said he had seen.
-
Sidewalk Fall: Google Maps Images Did Not Win Dismissal When Testimony the Defendants Submitted Backed the Injured Woman’s Photo (Then v Meridian Realty Inc., 1st Dept 2026)
A defendant that asks to dismiss a fall case because the injured person cannot say what made her fall still must prove that point, and the testimony it submits counts against it too. Here, the First Department reinstated a woman’s sidewalk fall claim against two defendants, because testimony they themselves submitted agreed that her photo of the defect fairly and accurately showed the area at the time, even though Google Maps images from before and after her fall did not show it.
-
Tripped Over a Drill Cord in a Doorway: Construction Worker Wins on Liability Under Labor Law 241(6), and Any Fault of Her Own Is Left for Trial (Logrono v City of New York, 1st Dept 2026)
A worker who proves a Labor Law 241(6) claim based on a specific Industrial Code violation can win on liability without first proving that she was free of fault herself. Here, the First Department granted a worker summary judgment on liability after she tripped on a hammer drill’s cord blocking a doorway, and left the question of her own comparative negligence for trial.
-
Finger Cut by a Circular Saw Run by a Co-Worker: Labor Law 241(6) Claim Reinstated Even Though the Injured Worker Was Not Running the Saw (Volquez v Wade Hampton Apts., Inc., 1st Dept 2026)
A Labor Law 241(6) claim depends on specific Industrial Code sections, and a worker hurt by a power saw with a faulty guard may rely on them even if someone else was running the saw. Here, the First Department reinstated a worker’s Labor Law 241(6) claim under three Industrial Code sections after a circular saw operated by a co-worker allegedly cut his finger, because his testimony that the bottom of the saw did not protect him from the blade and that the part securing the blade would get “stuck” raised questions of fact.
-
Slip on a Puddle Under a Dripping Supermarket Ceiling: The Landlord Stays in the Case Because the Lease Made It Responsible for the Roof (Love v Chang Li Supermarket, Inc., 1st Dept 2026)
A landlord that has leased a property to a tenant and given up possession and control is generally not responsible for conditions there, but it may be when the lease kept the repair that caused the hazard with the landlord. Here, the First Department reinstated an injured woman’s claim against a supermarket’s landlord, because the lease made the landlord responsible for structural repairs, including the roof, and the landlord did not affirmatively demonstrate that a roof leak was not the source of the puddle where she slipped; her own motion against the supermarket was denied, leaving notice, and her own comparative fault, for trial.
-
Chain Crash on the Verrazano Bridge: Access-A-Ride Passenger Wins on Liability as the Truck Driver’s Brake-Failure Claim Fails (Al-Hamid v New York City Tr. Auth., 2d Dept 2026)
A driver who blames a rear-end crash on brake failure must offer evidence that the problem was unexpected and that reasonable care had been used to keep the brakes in good working order. Here, the Second Department granted an Access-A-Ride passenger summary judgment on liability against the box truck that started a chain collision, because the defense’s own evidence indicated that the truck’s brakes were tested after the crash and were working properly, but it left the seatbelt defense for trial and kept her claims against the transit defendants dismissed.
-
Rear-End Crash in Heavy Traffic: Injured Driver Wins on Liability, and Her Serious Injury Claim Is Reinstated (Eagan v Gingo, 2d Dept 2026)
A driver who rear-ends a stopped or stopping car must give a non-negligent explanation, and a sudden stop that was foreseeable in the traffic conditions may not be enough. Here, the Second Department granted an injured driver summary judgment on liability, dismissed the comparative negligence defense, and reinstated her claim; on serious injury, the defense experts found significant limitations in her spine without adequately explaining why they called them voluntary, and the defense papers did not address her claim that the crash made earlier injuries worse.
-
Trip Over a Fence Around a Sidewalk Tree Well: The City Is Out for Lack of Prior Written Notice, but the Private Defendants Stay In (Rahman v B & K Realty Assoc., LLC, 2d Dept 2026)
In New York City, an abutting property owner generally is not responsible under the sidewalk law for injuries in a City-owned tree well, but it may be if it created the dangerous condition there. Here, the Second Department reinstated a pedestrian’s claim against four private defendants over a wooden fence around a tree well, because they did not affirmatively show that they had not created the condition, while it affirmed dismissal against the City, which showed it had no prior written notice.
-
Slip on Ice or Water on a Construction Staircase: Worker Wins on Liability Under Labor Law 241(6), but His Scaffold Law Claim Goes to Trial (Ramos v Lendlease (US) Constr. LMB Inc., 1st Dept 2026)
A Labor Law 241(6) claim depends on specific Industrial Code sections, and a worker who slips on ice or water may win on liability under the sections on slipping hazards and safe access, even when a Labor Law 240(1) claim from the same fall must go to trial. Here, the First Department affirmed summary judgment under Labor Law 241(6) for a worker who slipped on a construction site staircase, based largely on the defendants’ own photos and testimony, but reversed it under Labor Law 240(1), because there were questions whether the staircase was permanent and whether it was the only way to and from his work area.
-
Collision With a Fire Truck Going Through a Red Light on an Emergency Call: Claim Dismissed Under the Reckless Disregard Standard (Blackshear v City of Yonkers, 2d Dept 2026)
The driver of an emergency vehicle on an emergency call, using its lights and siren, may go through a red light after slowing down as necessary for safety, and for doing so can be held liable only if the driver acted in reckless disregard for the safety of others. Here, the Second Department affirmed the dismissal of a claim by a driver who had a green light when his vehicle collided with a City of Yonkers fire truck, because the fire truck was responding to an emergency call with its lights and siren on, and its driver slowed sufficiently before entering the intersection.
-
Crosswalk Fall in Queens: A “Dotted Line” on a Big Apple Map Was Not Prior Written Notice to the City (Melendez v City of New York, 2d Dept 2026)
New York City generally cannot be held liable for a defect in a street or crosswalk unless it had prior written notice of that specific defect, and a Big Apple map can serve as that notice only if it marks the defect that caused the fall. Here, the Second Department affirmed the dismissal of a man’s claim for a fall in a Queens crosswalk, because the City’s records search showed no prior written notice, and a “dotted line” on a Big Apple map did not match any defect symbol in the map’s key.
-
Trip on a Loose Sidewalk Paver: Owner’s Expert Inspected More Than Three Years Later, and the Dismissal Is Reversed (Velasquez v 88 Cypress, LLC, 2d Dept 2026)
A property owner asking a court to dismiss a trip-and-fall claim before trial must first show that there was no dangerous condition, that the defect was trivial, or that the owner neither created it nor had notice of it. Here, the Second Department reinstated a man’s claim that he tripped on a loose brick paver on the sidewalk in front of the defendant’s property, in part because the owner’s engineer inspected the area more than three years after the accident, with no showing that it was unchanged.
-
Bicycle Crash With a Truck: Dashcam Video and GPS Data Carry the Day, and Expert Opinions on Marijuana and Speed Are Found Speculative (Pemberton v Liberty Ashes Inc., 1st Dept 2026)
An expert’s opinion can raise a question of fact only if it rests on evidence in the record and explains how the expert reached it. Here, the First Department affirmed the dismissal of a bicyclist’s case against a truck driver and others, because the truck’s dashcam video showed that the truck had the green light and the cyclist rode through a red light, the video and testimony showed he was riding against one-way traffic, and his experts’ opinions that the driver was smoking marijuana and speeding were speculative.
-
Mold Painted Over Months Before a Ceiling Collapse: Resident’s Testimony Raises a Question of Notice (Martinez v 561 W. 144 Realty LLC, 1st Dept 2026)
A building owner that asks a court to dismiss an injury claim before trial must first show that it did not create the problem and did not know, and should not have known, about it, and its own evidence can undercut that showing. Here, the First Department affirmed the denial of an owner’s motion in a resident’s ceiling collapse case, because the owner itself submitted the resident’s testimony that the building’s manager and superintendent had seen mold on his bathroom ceiling two to three months earlier and painted over it.
-
Slip on Black Ice: Testimony and a Video Raise a Question Whether the Freezing Rain Had Stopped, Defeating a Storm-in-Progress Motion (Brown v Parkchester Preserv. Mgt., 1st Dept 2026)
A property owner generally is not liable for a fall on ice that forms during a storm, or for a reasonable time after it ends, but whether the storm was still going on can be a question of fact. Here, the First Department affirmed the denial of a condominium’s motion for summary judgment dismissing a black ice fall claim, because the woman’s testimony and a video of her fall raised a question of fact on whether the freezing rain had stopped, and the condominium did not show when the walkway was last inspected or cleaned.
-
Worker Struck by a Falling Beam Wins on Liability Even Though He Did Not Know Exactly What Made It Fall (Oliveira v 5462th Realty LLC, 1st Dept 2026)
Under Labor Law 240(1), a worker struck by a falling object that should have been secured may win on liability before trial, even if he cannot say exactly what made the object fall. Here, the First Department affirmed summary judgment for a worker hit in the back by a falling beam, based on his testimony, including that the object seen in a video his foreman recorded shortly after the accident was a beam, and the foreman’s testimony that a coworker said he had accidentally hit the beam on the floor above.
-
Passenger in a Stop-Sign Crash Wins on Liability, and the Other Driver Is Back in the Case (Williams v Dia, 1st Dept 2026)
A passenger who could not have caused a crash may win on liability before trial against a driver who was negligent under either version of the events, and a ruling that one driver was at fault does not by itself let the other driver out of the case. Here, the First Department affirmed summary judgment for a passenger against the driver who faced a stop sign, put the other driver back in the case, and held that her physiatrist’s opinion, based in part on MRIs taken after both crashes, raised a question of fact on causation.
-
Trip on a Bump in a City Park Path: Claim Dismissed Because the City Showed It Had No Prior Written Notice (Maldonado v City of New York, 1st Dept 2026)
New York City generally cannot be held liable for a defect covered by its prior written notice law unless it had written notice beforehand, but to win dismissal before trial the City must first show that it had none. Here, the First Department affirmed the dismissal of a claim by a man who alleged he tripped on a two- or three-inch bump in an asphalt path in Van Cortlandt Park, because the City’s records search showed no written complaints and his evidence did not raise a question of fact.
-
Who Was the General Contractor? The Owner’s Testimony, a Site Sign, and City Building Records Keep a Builder in an Injured Worker’s Case (Torres v Tinton Realty Group LLC, 1st Dept 2026)
A company sued by an injured construction worker may argue that it is not a proper defendant under the Labor Law, but whether it acted as the general contractor can depend on what it actually did on the project, not only on what its paperwork says. Here, the First Department held that the owner’s testimony, a sign at the site naming the builder as general contractor, and Department of Buildings records raised a question of fact, so the builder stays in the case.
-
Worker at Sidewalk Level Falls Over a Barrier Into a Below-Ground Entranceway: Labor Law 240(1) Applies (Nunez v Hispanic Socy. of Am., 1st Dept 2026)
Labor Law 240(1) can protect a worker standing at ground level when the work exposes him to a fall to a lower level and he is not given adequate safety devices. Here, the First Department granted partial summary judgment on liability under Labor Law 240(1), against The Hispanic Society of America, to a plumber’s assistant who fell over a barrier at sidewalk level into a below-ground entranceway, where his work required him to lean over that barrier.
-
Crash With a Driver Allegedly Working for Uber: Claims Against Uber Go Forward Because the Uber Companies Did Not Prove He Was an Independent Contractor (Rivera v M. GS Talukder, 2d Dept 2026)
A company can be held responsible for a crash caused by its employee on the job, but generally not for one caused by an independent contractor, and which one a driver was is usually a question for the jury. Here, the Second Department reversed the dismissal of an injured woman’s claims against three Uber companies, holding that they failed to eliminate all questions of fact about whether the driver was working as an independent contractor, rather than as their employee, when the collision happened.
-
Fall on the Riegelmann Boardwalk: City’s “No Prior Written Notice” Defense Fails Because Its Records Search Was Not Shown to Be Complete (Young v City of New York, 2d Dept 2026)
A New York City law generally makes the City liable for a defect in its streets and sidewalks only if it had prior written notice of it, but to have a claim dismissed on that ground before trial, the City must first show that it had none. Here, the Second Department reversed the dismissal of a man’s claim for a fall on the Riegelmann Boardwalk in Brooklyn, because the City’s affidavit did not say unequivocally that its records search found no prior written notice, and did not show that all the relevant records were searched.
-
Rear-End Crash Goes to Trial: Other Driver Swore the Car Ahead Stopped Suddenly “for No Apparent Reason” (Ruiz v Town of Southampton, 2d Dept 2026)
In New York, a driver who rear-ends a stopped or stopping vehicle is presumed negligent and must give a non-negligent explanation for the crash. Here, the Second Department affirmed the denial of an injured driver’s motion for summary judgment on fault, because the other driver’s sworn statement that the plaintiff made “a sudden stop for no apparent reason” conflicted with the plaintiff’s account.
-
400-Pound Beam and a Wet Floor: A Worker’s Testimony That He Also Slipped Sends His Labor Law 240(1) Claim to Trial (Mema v Procida Constr. Corp., 1st Dept 2026)
Labor Law 240(1) may cover a worker hurt when a heavy object he is carrying falls even a short distance, but if the record shows another possible cause, the question may be left for trial. Here, the First Department modified the order to deny a worker’s motion for summary judgment under Labor Law 240(1), because he testified that his foot slipped on a wet floor within a split second of a 400-pound beam falling onto it and that he did not know which happened first.
-
Did the Accident Happen? Defense Evidence, Including a Biomechanics Expert, Sends a Worker’s Labor Law 240(1) Claim to Trial (Gonzalez v Chatsworth Bldrs. LLC, 1st Dept 2026)
An injured worker may win on liability without a trial even if no one saw the accident, as long as nothing in the record contradicts his account or raises a question about his credibility. Here, the First Department modified the order to deny a worker’s motion for summary judgment under Labor Law 240(1), because a sign-out sheet, 17 statements from people at the project, a biomechanics expert, and three examining doctors, taken together, raised questions whether the accident happened at all, whether it happened as he described, and whether it caused his injuries.
-
Fall Blamed on Low Lighting in a Restaurant: The Landlord Is Out of the Case Because the Staff Set the Lights (Mella v Russian Samovar, Inc., 1st Dept 2026)
A landlord that has leased out a property, and is responsible under the lease for structural repairs, is generally not responsible for a condition that is not structural. Here, the First Department affirmed the dismissal of the claims against a restaurant’s landlord, because the low lighting the plaintiff blamed for the fall was set by the restaurant’s employees, and the plaintiff’s expert did not connect the other conditions listed to the fall.
-
Left Turn Around a Truck Blocking the Intersection: Turning Driver’s Claim Reinstated (Sanchez-Rodriguez v Bruce, 1st Dept 2026)
A driver turning left must generally yield to oncoming traffic, but a driver with a green light must also yield to other traffic lawfully within the intersection, so a left turn does not automatically mean the turning driver was at fault. Here, the First Department reinstated a left-turning driver’s claim because the record did not conclusively show which driver had to yield after a concrete truck blocked the intersection.
-
Scaffold Fall: Worker Wins on Liability as the Court Rejects a Defense Biomechanical Expert’s Opinion (Latazela v Compass Six Owner LLC, 1st Dept 2026)
An expert’s opinion that disregards consistent evidence that the injured person fell and was hurt, or does not explain how the expert reached it, may not be enough to require a trial. Here, the First Department affirmed partial summary judgment on liability under Labor Law 240(1) and 241(6) for a worker who fell 11 to 12 feet from a plank on a scaffold that moved, rejecting the defendants’ biomechanical expert’s opinion as speculative.
-
Car Crash Injury Claims Go Forward: A Biomechanical Engineer’s Report Could Not Replace a Medical Opinion (Bonilla-Acosta v Max Servs. Corp., 2d Dept 2026)
In a New York car accident case, a defendant that asks the court to dismiss an injury claim because there was no “serious injury” must first make that showing with competent medical evidence. Here, the Second Department affirmed the denial of two defendants’ motion, holding that their biomechanical engineer could speak to the forces in the crash but did not show he was qualified to give a medical opinion on whether the accident caused the injuries.
-
Rear-End Crash: Passengers Win on Fault Before Depositions Despite the Truck Driver’s Later Affidavit (Escobar v Sanchez, 2d Dept 2026)
When a vehicle that is stopped or slowing is hit from behind, the rear driver is presumed negligent and must give a non-negligent explanation for the crash. Here, the Second Department affirmed summary judgment on fault for two passengers in a car struck in the rear by a tractor-trailer, holding that the truck driver’s affidavit, which contradicted his statements recorded in the police accident report, raised only a “feigned issue of fact,” and that the motions were not premature.
-
Trip on a Fire Hydrant Base: Claim Against the Building Owner Dismissed Because the City Was Responsible for the Hydrant (Fung v Exxon Mobil Oil Corp., 2d Dept 2026)
In New York City, the owner of the building or lot that a sidewalk runs in front of (the “abutting” owner) must keep that sidewalk reasonably safe, but it may not be responsible for a fire hydrant on the sidewalk that it does not own, control, or maintain. Here, the Second Department affirmed the dismissal of a pedestrian’s claim against the abutting owner after his foot caught on a fire hydrant base, because the owner showed that the City was responsible for maintaining the hydrant.
-
Fall Through Open Floor Doors at a Bar: The Landlord That Leased Out the Space Stays in the Case (Cutter v Bayard’s Ale House, 1st Dept 2026)
A landlord that has handed over a property to a tenant is generally not responsible for its condition, but it may be held liable if it kept a right to reenter to make repairs and a specific building safety law was violated. Here, the First Department affirmed the denial of summary judgment to the landlord of a Greenwich Village bar where a patron fell down basement stairs, because the landlord did not address the statutes and codes the patron cited.
-
Hurt Catching a Falling Beam: Labor Law 240(1) Covers a Worker Who Neither Fell Nor Was Struck (Mitchell v Pullman SST, 1st Dept 2026)
Labor Law 240(1), often known as “the Scaffold Law,” may protect a construction worker who is hurt trying to keep a heavy load from falling, even if he never fell and nothing struck him. Here, the First Department affirmed partial summary judgment on liability for a foreman who hurt his back catching a 230-pound beam that slipped from a coworker’s hand, and held that being the foreman did not make him the sole proximate cause of the accident.
-
Ladder Struck by Falling Plywood: Worker Wins on Labor Law 240(1), Whether He Fell From the Second Step or the Sixth (De Souza v 4720 Third Ave LLC, 1st Dept 2026)
A worker who falls from an unsecured ladder that suddenly moves may win on liability under Labor Law 240(1), even if the fall is from only a few feet. Here, the First Department modified the trial court’s order to grant partial summary judgment on liability to a worker whose ladder was struck by a falling piece of plywood he was removing from a ceiling, holding that it did not matter whether he was on the sixth step or the second.
-
Ceiling Collapse After Repeated Leak Complaints: Injured Man Wins Summary Judgment on Liability (Wims v River Park Bronx Apts., 1st Dept 2026)
When the people responsible for a building know about a dangerous condition and do not fix it, an injured person may be able to win on fault without a trial. Here, the First Department affirmed summary judgment on liability for a man hurt when part of a ceiling fell, because the defendants had actual notice of a leak and it appeared they had simply plastered and painted over the ceiling two weeks before the accident.
-
Ambulance Allegedly Sent Without Oxygen: Wrongful Death Claim Against NYC Fails for Lack of a Special Duty (Davis v City of New York, 2d Dept 2026)
When a city sends an ambulance in response to a 911 call, it is performing a governmental function, and it can be held liable only if it owed the injured person a “special duty.” Here, the Second Department held that the City’s motion to dismiss a wrongful death complaint should have been granted because no such duty was alleged, even though a discovery sanction barred the City from offering evidence on liability.
-
Bus Video Defeats a Passenger’s Claim Against NYC Transit Despite the Other Driver’s Sworn Account (Hyejun Cho v NYCTA, 2d Dept 2026)
When clear video shows how a crash happened, a court may decide fault without a trial, even if a driver swears to a different version. Here, the Second Department affirmed the dismissal of a car passenger’s claims against the New York City Transit Authority and its bus driver, because the bus video conclusively established that the driver of the car she was riding in was the sole proximate cause of the crash.
-
Late Motion Could Not Defeat a Worker’s Labor Law 240(1) Claim, but His Late Industrial Code Amendment Failed Too (Cambero-Minaya v 211 Schermerhorn Dev., LLC, 2d Dept 2026)
After the note of issue is filed, deadlines bind both sides: a late summary judgment motion without good cause must be denied without considering the merits, and a late change to the bill of particulars ordinarily needs special and extraordinary circumstances. Here, the Second Department reinstated a worker’s Labor Law 240(1) and related claims because the owner and general contractor moved too late, but left his Labor Law 241(6) claim dismissed because he sought to add Industrial Code sections about nine months after the note of issue.
-
Car Crash Claims Against Two Defendants Dismissed Where the Treating Doctor First Saw the Patient Three Months Later (Gomez v Uber Tech., Inc., 1st Dept 2026)
In a New York car accident case, an injured person who claims a “serious injury” needs admissible medical proof linking the injuries to the accident, and that proof must answer any defense claim that the injuries are old, degenerative conditions. Here, the First Department affirmed the dismissal of the claims against two of the defendants because the early treatment records were unsworn and uncertified, and the treating doctor first examined the plaintiff three months after the collision, so he had not seen the injuries when they were new.
-
E-Bike Rider’s Claim Against NYC Transit: An Early Summary Judgment Motion Was Not Premature, but Unclear Video Was Not Enough (Komlan v Belisle, 1st Dept 2026)
The fact that depositions have not occurred in a motor vehicle accident case does not necessarily preclude the court from granting summary judgment, but the proof must still show the defendants’ negligence clearly. Here, the First Department held that an e-bike rider’s motion against the New York City Transit Authority was not premature, but because the surveillance video did not clearly depict the accident, it affirmed the trial court’s denial of the motion.
-
An Affirmation Without CPLR 2106’s Perjury Language Is Not Evidence in Admissible Form (Interasian v Park, 1st Dept 2026)
Every affirmation must explicitly state that it is made “under the penalties of perjury under the laws of New York, which may include a fine or imprisonment” as CPLR 2106 requires. Here, the First Department reversed a $9.2 million judgment, in part because all of the plaintiff’s evidence came in through an attorney affirmation that failed to substantially conform to that language.
Decision Day summarizes and comments on published court decisions. It is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts. Unless an entry says otherwise, The Eskesen Law Firm did not represent any party in these cases.
Legal Help When You Need It
Fill out the form to request a consultation and we will be in touch as soon as possible.
(212) 433-4500Toll-free 1-800-321-NYLAW (1-800-321-6952)
- Calls answered live 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
- We speak English, Spanish and Portuguese.
- Main office
450 Seventh Avenue, Suite 1808
New York, NY 10123 - Downtown office
30 Wall Street, Suite 804
New York, NY 10005
By appointment only