Premises
Decisions on injuries caused by dangerous conditions on property, such as slip, trip, and fall cases.
-
Sidewalk Fall: Google Maps Images Did Not Win Dismissal When Testimony the Defendants Submitted Backed the Injured Woman’s Photo (Then v Meridian Realty Inc., 1st Dept 2026)
A defendant that asks to dismiss a fall case because the injured person cannot say what made her fall still must prove that point, and the testimony it submits counts against it too. Here, the First Department reinstated a woman’s sidewalk fall claim against two defendants, because testimony they themselves submitted agreed that her photo of the defect fairly and accurately showed the area at the time, even though Google Maps images from before and after her fall did not show it.
-
Slip on a Puddle Under a Dripping Supermarket Ceiling: The Landlord Stays in the Case Because the Lease Made It Responsible for the Roof (Love v Chang Li Supermarket, Inc., 1st Dept 2026)
A landlord that has leased a property to a tenant and given up possession and control is generally not responsible for conditions there, but it may be when the lease kept the repair that caused the hazard with the landlord. Here, the First Department reinstated an injured woman’s claim against a supermarket’s landlord, because the lease made the landlord responsible for structural repairs, including the roof, and the landlord did not affirmatively demonstrate that a roof leak was not the source of the puddle where she slipped; her own motion against the supermarket was denied, leaving notice, and her own comparative fault, for trial.
-
Trip Over a Fence Around a Sidewalk Tree Well: The City Is Out for Lack of Prior Written Notice, but the Private Defendants Stay In (Rahman v B & K Realty Assoc., LLC, 2d Dept 2026)
In New York City, an abutting property owner generally is not responsible under the sidewalk law for injuries in a City-owned tree well, but it may be if it created the dangerous condition there. Here, the Second Department reinstated a pedestrian’s claim against four private defendants over a wooden fence around a tree well, because they did not affirmatively show that they had not created the condition, while it affirmed dismissal against the City, which showed it had no prior written notice.
-
Trip on a Loose Sidewalk Paver: Owner’s Expert Inspected More Than Three Years Later, and the Dismissal Is Reversed (Velasquez v 88 Cypress, LLC, 2d Dept 2026)
A property owner asking a court to dismiss a trip-and-fall claim before trial must first show that there was no dangerous condition, that the defect was trivial, or that the owner neither created it nor had notice of it. Here, the Second Department reinstated a man’s claim that he tripped on a loose brick paver on the sidewalk in front of the defendant’s property, in part because the owner’s engineer inspected the area more than three years after the accident, with no showing that it was unchanged.
-
Elevator Accident: Claim Against the Elevator Service Company Dismissed as Too Late, Because Serving a Different Company First Was Not a “Mere Misnomer” (Turner v Pride & Servs. El. Co. Inc., 1st Dept 2026)
An injured person must sue the right company before the deadline to sue runs out, and adding it later may be too late. Here, the First Department affirmed the dismissal, as time-barred, of a woman’s injury claims against the elevator company that had held the contract to service the elevator, because serving a different company earlier did not bring it into the case, and it affirmed summary judgment for the company that bought that contract without taking on liability for past injuries.
-
Mold Painted Over Months Before a Ceiling Collapse: Resident’s Testimony Raises a Question of Notice (Martinez v 561 W. 144 Realty LLC, 1st Dept 2026)
A building owner that asks a court to dismiss an injury claim before trial must first show that it did not create the problem and did not know, and should not have known, about it, and its own evidence can undercut that showing. Here, the First Department affirmed the denial of an owner’s motion in a resident’s ceiling collapse case, because the owner itself submitted the resident’s testimony that the building’s manager and superintendent had seen mold on his bathroom ceiling two to three months earlier and painted over it.
-
Slip on Black Ice: Testimony and a Video Raise a Question Whether the Freezing Rain Had Stopped, Defeating a Storm-in-Progress Motion (Brown v Parkchester Preserv. Mgt., 1st Dept 2026)
A property owner generally is not liable for a fall on ice that forms during a storm, or for a reasonable time after it ends, but whether the storm was still going on can be a question of fact. Here, the First Department affirmed the denial of a condominium’s motion for summary judgment dismissing a black ice fall claim, because the woman’s testimony and a video of her fall raised a question of fact on whether the freezing rain had stopped, and the condominium did not show when the walkway was last inspected or cleaned.
-
Trip on a Bump in a City Park Path: Claim Dismissed Because the City Showed It Had No Prior Written Notice (Maldonado v City of New York, 1st Dept 2026)
New York City generally cannot be held liable for a defect covered by its prior written notice law unless it had written notice beforehand, but to win dismissal before trial the City must first show that it had none. Here, the First Department affirmed the dismissal of a claim by a man who alleged he tripped on a two- or three-inch bump in an asphalt path in Van Cortlandt Park, because the City’s records search showed no written complaints and his evidence did not raise a question of fact.
-
Fall on the Riegelmann Boardwalk: City’s “No Prior Written Notice” Defense Fails Because Its Records Search Was Not Shown to Be Complete (Young v City of New York, 2d Dept 2026)
A New York City law generally makes the City liable for a defect in its streets and sidewalks only if it had prior written notice of it, but to have a claim dismissed on that ground before trial, the City must first show that it had none. Here, the Second Department reversed the dismissal of a man’s claim for a fall on the Riegelmann Boardwalk in Brooklyn, because the City’s affidavit did not say unequivocally that its records search found no prior written notice, and did not show that all the relevant records were searched.
-
Fall Blamed on Low Lighting in a Restaurant: The Landlord Is Out of the Case Because the Staff Set the Lights (Mella v Russian Samovar, Inc., 1st Dept 2026)
A landlord that has leased out a property, and is responsible under the lease for structural repairs, is generally not responsible for a condition that is not structural. Here, the First Department affirmed the dismissal of the claims against a restaurant’s landlord, because the low lighting the plaintiff blamed for the fall was set by the restaurant’s employees, and the plaintiff’s expert did not connect the other conditions listed to the fall.
-
Suing the Right Owner in Time: Claim Dismissed Because the Property’s Owners Were Added Too Late (Gonzalez v Country Manor Apts., 1st Dept 2026)
In New York, an injured person generally has three years to sue, and that time can run out if the lawsuit names the wrong party and the right one is not brought in before the deadline. Here, the First Department affirmed the dismissal of the claim against the companies that owned the property where the plaintiff alleged he was hurt, because he did not seek to add them until almost four years after the accident.
-
Porter Struck by Loose Plywood: No Scaffold Law Claim, but Labor Law 200 Reaches Beyond Construction Sites (Neil v Areeba, Inc., 2d Dept 2026)
Labor Law 240(1), often known as the Scaffold Law, protects workers engaged in certain kinds of work on a building or structure, but not routine maintenance, while Labor Law 200’s duty to keep a workplace safe is not limited to construction work. Here, the Second Department held that a porter struck by loose sheets of plywood could not add a Labor Law 240(1) claim to his case, but should have been allowed to add a Labor Law 200 claim.
-
Trip on a Fire Hydrant Base: Claim Against the Building Owner Dismissed Because the City Was Responsible for the Hydrant (Fung v Exxon Mobil Oil Corp., 2d Dept 2026)
In New York City, the owner of the building or lot that a sidewalk runs in front of (the “abutting” owner) must keep that sidewalk reasonably safe, but it may not be responsible for a fire hydrant on the sidewalk that it does not own, control, or maintain. Here, the Second Department affirmed the dismissal of a pedestrian’s claim against the abutting owner after his foot caught on a fire hydrant base, because the owner showed that the City was responsible for maintaining the hydrant.
-
Dram Shop Act: A Widow May Sue a Restaurant for Her Own Loss of Support, but Her Husband’s Estate May Not (Vera v BH Broadway Owner LLC, 1st Dept 2026)
New York’s Dram Shop Act can let a spouse who loses financial support when a drinker is hurt or killed sue the business that unlawfully served the drinker, but it gives no claim to the drinker or his estate. Here, the First Department let a widow’s own loss-of-support claim go forward against a restaurant that, she alleges, kept serving her visibly intoxicated husband before he fell down its stairs, but held that the claim fails insofar as it was brought on behalf of anyone else, including his estate.
-
Fall Through Open Floor Doors at a Bar: The Landlord That Leased Out the Space Stays in the Case (Cutter v Bayard’s Ale House, 1st Dept 2026)
A landlord that has handed over a property to a tenant is generally not responsible for its condition, but it may be held liable if it kept a right to reenter to make repairs and a specific building safety law was violated. Here, the First Department affirmed the denial of summary judgment to the landlord of a Greenwich Village bar where a patron fell down basement stairs, because the landlord did not address the statutes and codes the patron cited.
-
Ceiling Collapse After Repeated Leak Complaints: Injured Man Wins Summary Judgment on Liability (Wims v River Park Bronx Apts., 1st Dept 2026)
When the people responsible for a building know about a dangerous condition and do not fix it, an injured person may be able to win on fault without a trial. Here, the First Department affirmed summary judgment on liability for a man hurt when part of a ceiling fell, because the defendants had actual notice of a leak and it appeared they had simply plastered and painted over the ceiling two weeks before the accident.
-
Slip-and-Fall Video Overwritten After a Preservation Letter: Adverse Inference Charge Ordered (Fernandez v Port Auth. of N.Y. & N.J., 2d Dept 2026)
Where there is a question of fact as to the time a preservation letter is received and the time when the video is destroyed, the jury is to determine whether “spoliation of evidence” occurred. Here, in a slip-and-fall case against an airline, the Second Department held that “[t]he appropriate sanction” for any spoliation “would be an adverse inference charge” against the airline.
Decision Day summarizes and comments on published court decisions. It is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts. Unless an entry says otherwise, The Eskesen Law Firm did not represent any party in these cases.
Legal Help When You Need It
Fill out the form to request a consultation and we will be in touch as soon as possible.
(212) 433-4500Toll-free 1-800-321-NYLAW (1-800-321-6952)
- Calls answered live 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
- We speak English, Spanish and Portuguese.
- Main office
450 Seventh Avenue, Suite 1808
New York, NY 10123 - Downtown office
30 Wall Street, Suite 804
New York, NY 10005
By appointment only