Decision Day

Pothole Fall in Brooklyn: A Citizen’s Report With a Photo of a Different Pothole Revived the Claim Against the City (Hernandez v City of New York, 2d Dept 2026)

This page summarizes and comments on a published court decision. It is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts. Unless this page says otherwise, The Eskesen Law Firm did not represent any party in this case.

Bottom line

New York City generally can be held liable for a street defect only if it had prior written notice of it, but the law does not require that notice to pinpoint the exact spot. Here, the Second Department reinstated a woman’s claim for a pothole fall at a Brooklyn intersection, because a citizen’s report of a pothole at that corner, closed 13 days before her fall, reasonably identified the area even though its photograph showed a different pothole.

The case

Court
Appellate Division, Second Department
Decided
November 12, 2026
Case
Hernandez v City of New York
Citation
2026 NY Slip Op 06700
Official text
Read the decision on the New York courts’ official reporter site

The facts

The plaintiff alleged that on May 24, 2016, she tripped on a pothole at the southwest corner of New York Avenue and Avenue H in Brooklyn, and she sued the City of New York. The City moved for summary judgment, arguing that it had no prior written notice of that pothole, because a citizen’s report of a pothole on the southwest corner included a photograph of a different pothole. In opposition, she offered the testimony of the City laborer who supervised the crew that repaired four potholes at the intersection on May 11, 2016. His practice was to go to the address or intersection given and search for potholes to fill, and he had never received photographs or more specific locations. The Supreme Court, Kings County, granted the City’s motion, and she appealed.

The holding

The Second Department reversed and denied the motion. Administrative Code § 7-201(c) imposes liability on the City only for defects “that its officials have been actually notified exist at a specified location” (2026 NY Slip Op 06700, *1). But “[t]he Administrative Code does not set forth any requirements for the specificity of the notice,” so “a notice is sufficient if it brought the particular condition at issue to the attention of the authorities” (id.). A recent notice “that does not provide an exact location, but which nevertheless reasonably identifies the area of the purported defect, may give rise to a question of fact for the jury as to the sufficiency of the notice” (id. at *2). The City’s own papers included a citizen’s report, made on May 5, 2016, of a pothole at the “SOUTHWEST INTERSECTION OF AVE ‘H’ AND NY AVE,” marked “closed” on May 11, 2016, “only 13 days before the plaintiff’s fall” (id.). “Although the photograph attached to the report depicted a separate pothole at another corner of the intersection, the citizen’s report nevertheless reasonably identified the area of the purported defect and was not too remote in time or location to bring the particular condition at issue to the attention of the authorities” (id.). So the City “failed to establish, prima facie, that it did not have prior written notice of the subject pothole” (id.). That is, it did not make the first showing needed to win without a trial.

What changed

Nothing new: this applies settled law, including the court’s earlier decisions in Leblanc v City of New York (241 AD3d 1320 [2d Dept 2025]) and Bochner v Town of Monroe (169 AD3d 631 [2d Dept 2019]).

What it means

  1. In New York City, a claim against the City over a defect in a street or sidewalk generally requires proof that it had prior written notice of it, unless an exception applies.
  2. The written notice does not have to give the exact location. One that reasonably identifies the area, and is close in time, may be enough to send the question to a jury.
  3. Prior written notice is different from the Notice of Claim, which generally must be served within 90 days of the fall.

Our view

Commentary by Frank N. Eskesen. This section is opinion.

We note that the City’s own papers helped the injured woman here, much as testimony the defendants themselves submitted did in our entry on Then v Meridian Realty Inc. (First Department, November 10, 2026). The crew’s practice was to go to the intersection and look for potholes, not to match a photograph. Prior written notice laws can be harsh on people hurt by a defect in a street or sidewalk. Courts read them strictly (“Prior written notice provisions, enacted in derogation of common law, are always strictly construed,” Gorman v Town of Huntington, 12 NY3d 275, 279 [2009]), and the Court of Appeals has recognized only two exceptions (Amabile v City of Buffalo, 93 NY2d 471 [1999]). So this decision is a refreshing reprieve. A photograph of the wrong pothole did not end the case. We believe a report that named the very corner where she later fell, and was marked closed the day a City crew filled potholes at that intersection, did what the law asks of written notice. It brought the condition to the City’s attention. The same day, the same court let a village sidewalk case go forward on another route, in Anderson v County of Suffolk, Inc. (2026 NY Slip Op 06676). There was a question whether the village itself created the hazard, a metal remnant of a removed parking signpost. Two lessons: 1. After a fall on a city street or sidewalk, photograph the exact spot and the surrounding corner, and get legal advice promptly. The Notice of Claim deadline is short, and complaints that other people made before your fall may matter (see our post on New York City’s prior written notice rule). 2. For lawyers, ask for every citizen report and repair record for the whole intersection, not just the exact spot. A complaint does not need a perfect photograph to do its job.

Topics

Notice of Claim and Municipal LiabilitySummary Judgment

Court: Second Department. Year: 2026. Statutes: Administrative Code of City of NY § 7-201(c). Result: reversed.

Reviewed by Frank N. Eskesen, admitted in New York since 2000. Decided November 12, 2026. Posted November 16, 2026.

Questions about your own accident?

Call us for a free consultation. Calls answered live 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.

(212) 433-4500

All Decision Day entries

Free consultation

Legal Help When You Need It

Fill out the form to request a consultation and we will be in touch as soon as possible.

(212) 433-4500

Toll-free 1-800-321-NYLAW (1-800-321-6952)

  • Calls answered live 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
  • We speak English, Spanish and Portuguese.
  • Main office
    450 Seventh Avenue, Suite 1808
    New York, NY 10123
  • Downtown office
    30 Wall Street, Suite 804
    New York, NY 10005
    By appointment only

Send us a message

There is no charge to ask. We will get back to you as soon as possible. For anything urgent, call (212) 433-4500.

The date, the place and the type of accident are enough; we will get the details when we speak with you.