This page summarizes and comments on a published court decision. It is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts. Unless this page says otherwise, The Eskesen Law Firm did not represent any party in this case.
Bottom line
A town with a prior written notice law that seeks dismissal on that ground must first show that it did not receive written notice of the defect, and courts read those laws strictly against the town. Here, the Third Department held that the Town of Colonie could not win dismissal of a bicyclist’s sidewalk case before discovery. The County had emailed the man alleged to head the Town’s highway department about the sidewalk’s condition roughly a year before the fall, and the record did not show whether that email was, or should have been, forwarded within the Town, or who in the Town now fills the role of the superintendent of highways.
The case
- Court
- Appellate Division, Third Department
- Decided
- November 12, 2026
- Case
- Cisario v Abele Tractor & Equip. Co., Inc.
- Citation
- 2026 NY Slip Op 06603
- Official text
- Read the decision on the New York courts’ official reporter site
The facts
In August 2023, the person alleged to head the Town of Colonie’s highway department received an email from the County of Albany about the condition of the sidewalk in front of the business of Abele Tractor & Equipment Company, Inc., in the Town. The Town is charged with maintaining that sidewalk. About a year later, the plaintiff fell while riding a bicycle on the damaged sidewalk and was injured. He served a Notice of Claim on the Town, which denied the claim for lack of prior written notice. He sued. Before answering, the Town moved to dismiss the complaint on the ground that it had not received prior written notice under Town Law § 65-a(2) or the Town’s code. The Supreme Court, Albany County, denied the motion, and the Town appealed.
The holding
The Third Department unanimously affirmed. The court explained that “it is the municipality’s initial burden to demonstrate that it did not receive the requisite written notice” (2026 NY Slip Op 06603, *1), and that “[b]ecause local laws requiring such notice are in derogation of the common law, they are strictly construed against the municipality and liberally in favor of the citizen” (id. at *2, quoting Calabrese v City of Albany). Town Law § 65-a(2) requires that written notice be “actually given to the town clerk or to the town superintendent of highways,” and the Town’s code provides for notice to the town attorney. At oral argument, the Town’s lawyer told the court that the code did not replace the state law, so notice could go to any of the three (id.). The Town’s attorney stated in an affidavit that he had searched the Town’s records kept by his office and found no record of prior written notice. But “it was established that written notice of the sidewalk’s condition had been provided to Romano — allegedly the head of the Town’s highway department — prior to plaintiff’s accident” (id.). “Nothing in the record indicates whether that written notice should have been, or was, internally forwarded to anyone else in the highway department or to the Town’s attorney or his subordinates” (id.), and, because the Town had abolished the office of superintendent of highways, it was “unclear who in the Town is the functional equivalent” of one (id.). So the motion was properly denied, because “there is a need for discovery” (id.).
What changed
Nothing new: this applies settled law, including the Court of Appeals’ decision in Calabrese v City of Albany (43 NY3d 167 [2024]).
What it means
- Where a town has a prior written notice law, it generally cannot be held liable for a sidewalk defect unless it received written notice and did not fix the defect within a reasonable time.
- To win dismissal on this ground, the town must first show that it did not receive written notice. A search of one office’s records may not be enough when the law lets notice go to other officials.
- Written notice does not have to come from the injured person. Here, the notice at issue came from another government, the County, by email.
Our view
Commentary by Frank N. Eskesen. This section is opinion.
We believe the court was right not to end the case on the town attorney’s search of his own office’s files. The notice went to the man alleged to head the highway department, and a town has many offices. The absence of a record in one of them says little about what another official received. Read this decision alongside our entries on Hernandez v City of New York (Second Department, November 12, 2026) and Shearing v Town of Gates (Fourth Department, November 13, 2026). On November 12 and 13, 2026, three of the four Departments of the Appellate Division kept injured people’s claims alive against a prior written notice defense. Two lessons: 1. If you are hurt by a defect on a public sidewalk or road, get legal advice promptly. A Notice of Claim deadline may apply (generally 90 days), and complaints about the defect, by anyone, may matter. 2. For lawyers, look beyond the files of the office that searched. Ask every office the statute or local code names, and other governments that may have reported the defect, for any written notice (see our post on New York City’s prior written notice rule).
Topics
Court: Third Department. Year: 2026. Statutes: Town Law § 65-a(2); CPLR 3211(a)(7), (d). Result: affirmed.
Reviewed by Frank N. Eskesen, admitted in New York since 2000. Decided November 12, 2026. Posted November 18, 2026.
Questions about your own accident?
Call us for a free consultation. Calls answered live 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.