This page summarizes and comments on a published court decision. It is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts. Unless this page says otherwise, The Eskesen Law Firm did not represent any party in this case.
Bottom line
Where a town has a prior written notice law, a person hurt by a dangerous condition in a town-owned parking lot generally cannot win without proof that the town had written notice of it, unless an exception applies, such as the town’s own affirmative negligence in creating the hazard. Here, a divided Fourth Department reinstated a woman’s claim against the Town of Gates, holding that testimony and a meteorological expert’s opinion raised a question of fact whether the Town deliberately pushed snow onto the edge of a sidewalk and whether that snow melted and refroze to create a dangerous icy condition.
The case
- Court
- Appellate Division, Fourth Department
- Decided
- November 13, 2026
- Case
- Shearing v Town of Gates
- Citation
- 2026 NY Slip Op 06619
- Official text
- Read the decision on the New York courts’ official reporter site
The facts
The plaintiff alleges that she slipped and fell on an accumulation of black ice in a public parking lot owned and operated by the Town of Gates. According to the decision, she was transporting a suspect to the Gates Police Department at the time. She sued the Town and the Gates Police Department for premises liability and under Labor Law 200. The defendants moved for summary judgment, arguing among other things that they had not received prior written notice of the condition, as the Town’s code requires. The plaintiff cross-moved for partial summary judgment on issues including whether the ice was a dangerous condition and whether the defendants had constructive notice of it. The Supreme Court, Monroe County, granted the defendants’ motion and denied the cross-motion, and she appealed.
The holding
The Fourth Department modified the order by reinstating her premises liability claim against the Town. The court held that “[a] publicly-owned parking lot falls within the definition of a ‘highway’ and therefore prior [written] notice of [a] defect is required” where, as here, the town has a prior written notice law (2026 NY Slip Op 06619, *1, quoting Groninger v Village of Mamaroneck). The Town showed that it had no written notice. But the court quoted the rule that “a municipality’s act in piling snow as part of its snow removal efforts, which snow pile then melts and refreezes to create a dangerous icy condition, constitutes an affirmative act” (id. at *2). It held that “the deposition testimony submitted by plaintiff, combined with the opinion of plaintiff’s meteorological expert, is sufficient to raise a triable issue of fact whether the Town deliberately pushed snow onto the edge of the sidewalk and whether that snow then melted and refroze to create a dangerous icy condition” (id.). The rest of the order, including the dismissal of her claims against the Police Department and under Labor Law 200, was affirmed (id. at *2 to *3). One Justice dissented in part, finding no evidence that the Town created the specific patch of black ice (id. at *3 to *4).
What changed
Nothing new: this applies settled law, including the Court of Appeals’ decisions in Groninger v Village of Mamaroneck (17 NY3d 125 [2011]) and San Marco v Village/Town of Mount Kisco (16 NY3d 111 [2010]).
What it means
- A town-owned parking lot is treated as a “highway” under prior written notice laws. Where the town has such a law, it generally cannot be held liable without prior written notice of the condition, unless an exception applies. On a motion for summary judgment, the town must first show that it did not receive written notice.
- There are two recognized exceptions: the town created the defect through an affirmative act of negligence, or a special use of the property gave the town a special benefit. Here, the plaintiff did not raise a question of fact on the special use exception, because the lot, though used by Police Department staff, was also available to the public for parking.
- Failing to clear all the snow or ice is not enough for the first exception. Actively piling snow that then melts and refreezes into ice can be.
- Proof makes the difference. Here, testimony about the Town’s snow removal and a meteorological expert’s opinion were enough to raise a question of fact.
Our view
Commentary by Frank N. Eskesen. This section is opinion.
Read this decision alongside our entry on Hernandez v City of New York (Second Department, November 12, 2026). Prior written notice laws can be hard on people hurt on public property, and we believe it matters when courts apply the exceptions as written. A town that simply fails to clear all the ice has not created it. A town that piles snow where it will melt across a walkway and refreeze may have. The dissent shows how close the question was. Two lessons: 1. If you fall on ice on public property and are able to, photograph the spot and any nearby snow piles, note the time and weather, and get legal advice promptly. A Notice of Claim deadline may apply (generally 90 days). 2. For lawyers, find out how and where the municipality cleared the snow, and tie the meltwater to the spot where your client fell. Weather records and an expert can help (see our post on snow and ice falls).
Topics
Court: Fourth Department. Year: 2026. Statutes: General Municipal Law § 50-e(4); Labor Law § 200. Result: modified.
Reviewed by Frank N. Eskesen, admitted in New York since 2000. Decided November 13, 2026. Posted November 18, 2026.
Questions about your own accident?
Call us for a free consultation. Calls answered live 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.